H4 EAD Rule Latest News - Trump Administration Revoke and Lawsuit Status

H4 Visa EAD 2018 News – Lawsuit Status, Trump Administration Impact

In Immigration| Visas by Saurabh2233 Comments

Last Updated : May 23rd, 2018 . Check Timeline for full status updates by date.

Background:
For many years, since the H4 visa program inception, H-4 holders have not been provided with any work authorization. This changed on May 26, 2015 when USCIS passed the Employment Authorization for Certain H-4 Dependent Spouses rule. The H4 visa dependent spouses were eligible for work authorization EAD provided the H-1B spouse satisfies one of the below two:

  • Have an approved I-140, which is the immigration petition for foreign citizens to get Green Card or Permanent Residency in USA.
  • Have H1B visa status extended beyond 6 years under AC21 Act, which allows H1B holders seeking Green Card to work and stay in USA beyond 6 years, if their Green Card or Permanent Residency Application is Pending.

Soon after the H4 Visa EAD Rule was enacted, two things happened:
1. Thousands of H-4 spouses applied for H4 visa EAD  ( Employment Authorization Document) and got their first chance to work in US after many years of staying at home.
2. A lawsuit was filed against the H4 EAD rule to stop it from going into motion. More details on H4 EAD Lawsuit.

What’s the H4 EAD Lawsuit ?
‘Save Jobs USA’ (an organization comprised of IT workers who claim they lost their jobs to H-1B workers) filed its lawsuit against Department of Homeland Security (DHS) on April 23, 2015 before the rule was about to go live. The lawsuit was initially dismissed by a Federal district court in September 2016 (check references below ) as “Save Jobs USA” could not defend their lawsuit that H4 EAD holders will impact them. The plaintiffs, who is ‘Save Jobs USA’, filed an appeal to the United States Court of Appeal for the DC Circuit. The plaintiffs, claim two things:
1. The new rule has no protections for US workers and increases the pool of workers looking for jobs
2. DHS never had the authority to grant EADs to H-4 visa holders.

H4 EAD & Trump Administration Timeline – 
Since President Trump’s administration took office, there has been lot of speculation and rumors about what will happen to H-4 visa EAD rule. Below is the timeline of what has happened since President Trump took oath:

  • February 2, 2017 : The Trump administration requested ( filed a motion) a 60 day abeyance  (state of temporary inactivity ) to consider the issue and submit their brief ( response to consider the case).
  •  April 3, 2017 : The administration asked ( filed a new motion) for additional 180 day abeyance(state of temporary inactivity ) before they can provide their opinion. The Trump administration will update court every 60 days on the issue and update court before elapse of 180 days.
  • June 23, 2017 : The appeals court granted a stay on Jun 23rd, 2017 and asked both the parties, SAVE Jobs USA and DHS to file further motions on how they would like to proceed with the case by Sep 27, 2017.
  • September 20, 2017 :  SAVE Jobs USA has filed its motion stating that DHS has not taken any action and no publication of rule has been done in Federal register related to the H4 EAD rule and they requested for oral argument to conclude the case. They continue to tell that the delay would hurt american workers and new litigation would begin again.
  • September 27, 2017 :  DHS ( Trump administration)  filed a motion and requested the appeals court to hold the current H4 EAD case again in abeyance( which basically means hold on temporarily in suspension ), until December 31,2017.  The whole reason DHS have asked for this extension is to ensure that DHS and administration align their entire approach to implement Trump Executive Order 13788 on Buy American Hire American  and consider how to handle the H4 EAD rule as part of  overall view. For source, you will need PACER Login to view the entire document on court’s website.  Below is a screenshot of the actual info. H4-EAD-Lawsuit--Update-Extended-till-Dec-31-2017
  • November  17, 2017 :  There was a new request to extend the deadline, but court has denied the extension and has asked to continue and proceed and file their motions by January 2nd, 2018.  See belowH4 EAD News Update - 2017 November for January 2-2018
  • November 21st, 2017 (Unofficial – News) : A News article on Breitbart news says that there is a regulation drafted by DHS and is on the table to end the H4 visa EAD program.  Until we see this published, it is still a rumor. You can read the News on Breitbart.com  . There are so many speculations all over the place, please take every news with a pinch of salt.
  • December 14th, 2017 ( Official ) : DHS has published an agenda item “Removing H-4 Dependent Spouses from the Class of Aliens Eligible for Employment Authorization” today in the Fall 2017 Regulatory agenda. Basically all it says is that they intend to amend the original rule published for H4 EAD Rule in 2015  and potentially remove it as per the Buy American, Hire American EO by Trump Administration . It states that the DHS Secretary has authority to do as per INA regulations. Not many details published except that it is part of the agenda and they plan to remove it. We have no details on what happens to current H4 EAD holder working.  As of today, basically nothing changes as it is in proposed rule state.  We can expect progress or update on this in February 2018.   Below is a screenshot on what you see on regulations.gov  You can check the actual official info at Reginfo.govH4 EAD Work Rule Amendment 2017 Fall Agenda
  • December 22nd, 2017 ( Official ) : Both DHS and SAVE Jobs have filed respective motions, one to hold the case in abeyance (hold), other fo oral argument and not hold the case in abeyance. Below is quick summary.  
    • DHS Motion Summary : DHS has filed a motion to hold the lawsuit in abeyance ( basically on hold/suspension ) as they are in regulatory process of implementing the “Removal of  the H4 EAD” and they plan for Notice for proposed rule making ( NPRM) in February 2018. They say that having an oral argument now is of no use, when the H4 EAD rule is going to removed with regulation. As they are in process of removing, they are asking more time and will inform court in July, 2018 on the progress. You can check the document link in Official Documents section below.
    • SAVE Jobs Motion Summary : SAVE Jobs argues that in the first place DHS never had the authority to implement the H4 EAD rule without an act in Congress. They say that the regulatory process will take years, as the previous H4 EAD rule making took over 2 years from publication in regulatory agenda, and it will impact many of the Americans. Also, this process will lead to more lawsuits around the DHS rule to remove H4 EAD. The best path is to have oral argument and have a judgment.You can check the document link in Official Documents section below.
    • Current Status : Court is yet to review and give a decision on the motions filed by both. We will keep you posted.
    • Official Documents : You can read both the documents at H4 Visa EAD – Official Court Documents DHS, SAVE Jobs.
  • January 5th, 2018 ( Official ) : Many are waiting still for the update as we are past Jan 2nd, 2018 ,which was when we are supposed to hear something from the Court. As of now, there is no update on the case. We have checked court case updates, nothing has been published. Just to give you a perspective, the court has responded at least over 1.5 month after the motions were filed. As you can see below the actual court updates from the case on Court’s website, I have highlighted the one in RED, where court responded to the Motion filed. Now, if the same trend continues from court, we may not hear back anything end of January or February. Of course, just guessing here based on history. We will keep you posted, once there is an update. As nothing has happened, it can be assumed that Court has given DHS until July 2018 to hear the update. Again, we need official court response, will let you all know, once updated by court.
  • February 21st, 2018 ( Official ) : After a very long wait, finally today there is an update on the case by court.  They have ordered the case to be held in Abeyance ( basically hold) and denied the plea of oral argument by SAVE Jobs. As you can see below, they mention that, the reason for their decision is that they see the plan of rule-making  by DHS to propose rule to remove H4 EAD in February 2018.  DHS is asked is report status on the H4 EAD rule within 90 days from the order day, which is today Feb 21st, 2018 and also every 90 days after that.  Basically, DHS has to file an update with Court by May 22, 2018 on the H4 EAD rule-making.  Now, as far as the rule-making from DHS, nothing has been sent to OMB yet for review. So, we need to still wait.
    • Official Documents : Read Official Docs at H4 Visa EAD – Official Court Documents DHS, SAVE Jobs.
    • Next Steps : DHS to update Court regarding H4 EAD rule making by May 22, 2018.
    • H4 EAD Removal Rule Making Status : No rule is sent to OMB for review yet. Need to wait.
      H4 EAD Update February 2018 - Case to be Held in Abeyance
    • February 28th, 2018 ( Official ): DHS filed a status report with the DC Circuit Court stating that upon review by USCIS, they believe that draft of the regulation need to be revised further and they need some more time until June 2018.hey anticipate that it will be June 2018, when they can submit the proposed regulation to Office of Management and Budget for review and clearance  in time for publication.  The court document says that the decision to remove H4 EAD using regulation does not change, but they need more time. See below the document with sections highlighted.
      • Official Documents :Read Official Docs at H4 Visa EAD – Official Court Documents DHS, SAVE Jobs.
      • Next Steps : DHS to update court regarding H4 EAD removal regulation rule making process  in next 90 Days, maybe end of May 2018.
      • H4 EAD Removal Rule Making Status : Regulation will be revised further and send to OMB by June 2018. Need to wait.H4 EAD Update Lawsuit March 2018 News
    • March 26th, 2018 ( Official ): Few of the Members of Congress wrote to USCIS Secretary requesting to reconsider and not revoke the H4 EAD rule.  But, USCIS responded saying just that, they are working towards the president’s goal of Buy American and Hire American and everyone will get a chance to submit comments during the rule comments period to submit feedback.  See below. You can check the actual Request Letter and Respond from USCIS H4 EAD USCIS Updated Secretary April 2018
    • April 4th, 2018 ( Official ): USCIS Director wrote to Senate outlining various H1B and H4 changes in a letter and plans of USCIS. It also talks about their intention to remove H4 EAD and the regulation in planning. Below is the screenshot of the exact info. It clearly tells that they plan to remove it with regulation and public will get a chance to provide feedback during comment and notice period. Check original document of USCIS Letter sent to Senate Judiciary committee H4 EAD April 2018 News Update
    • May 10th, 2018 ( Official ) : H4 EAD Rule removal is now part of Spring 2018 agenda and the timeline has been updated to June 2018 for rule proposal and comment period. The current rule published in RegInfo.gov does not have much changes, except there is no need justification in the current rule proposal. See below the comparison. The green highlighted one is not there is Spring 2018 rule info. Check the actual rule info at Reginfo.gov Spring 2018 H4 Removal RuleSpring 2018 Regulatory Agenda H4 Visa EAD Rule Removal
  • May 16th, 2018 : A group of 130 members of congress lead by Rep. Pramila Jayapal and Rep. Mia Love,  signed a letter to the DHS asking Trump administration to reconsider its plans to remove H4 EAD rule  for certain spouses of H1B. You can read actual : Singed Letter H4 EAD 
  • May 23rd, 2018 ( Official ) :  Despite all the letters, etc. nothing has changed from DHS/ USCIS in their stance towards the rule removal. Yesterday,   DHS filed an update with the court indicating their stance and the progress with H4 EAD removal rule. It is a simple update and tells that the H4 EAD rule removal is in final clearance and will be sent to OMB for review and their plans remain unchanged for publication of NPRM for H4 EAD Removal   Below is  the most important piece of info clipped from the court document. You can check full  Official H4 EAD Court Documents H4 EAD Rule News Update May 2018 Latest Court Update

What Happens Now – Can H4 EAD be revoked by Trump Administration ? What’s the Impact ? Current Status ?
Spring 2018  Regulatory Agenda: As you can see most recent update above, we have agenda item called “Removing H-4 Dependent Spouses from the Class of Aliens Eligible for Employment Authorization”  that it is now part of the Spring 2018 Regulatory agenda. It was initially part of Fall 2017 agenda with a timeline of Feb 2018, but due to the complexity of the rule DHS asked for extended timeline with court for lawsuit and since then the timeline in the Spring 2018 regulatory agenda is updated with NPRM set to happen in June 2018.   Keeping the H4 lawsuit aside, now it has moved to a stage where the it has published agenda item to remove the H4 EAD rule.  June 2018 is the timeline for the rule to be sent to OMB for review. DHS and USCIS are working on the draft rule to send to OMB for review.   Until the new rule is published, we do not know much on what would happen to the current H4 EAD holders, etc. So, kind of unknown at this point. But, you can continue to file for H4 EAD, nothing is stopping you.

Members of Congress Letters, Requests – March, April 2018 News : Also, in the end of March many members of congress wrote to USCIS to reconsider removal of H4 EAD, but USCIS responded that they are framing many policies based on Buy American and Hire American EO and public will be given chance to give comments. Also, similar letter was sent in April, to Senate judiciary committee indicating that USCIS is in process of publishing regulation to remove H4 EAD. The overall message from USCIS is that they are clear on publishing regulation to remove H4 EAD. We have to wait and see, what they will do with the comments.

May 2018 News Update : Despite all the letters from members of congress, the most recent update from DHS to court on May 23, 2018 is that they will go ahead with NPRM once the final clearance is complete.

H4 EAD Lawsuit Update: On the lawsuit side, Court ordered on Feb 21st, 2018 to hold the case in Abeyance ( basically hold) and asked DHS to report the status within 90 days on the H4 EAD removal rule-making. Also, court denied the motion by SAVE Jobs for oral hearing…  As updated above, DHS updated court that they need more time to send the draft regulation to send to Office of Management and Budget (OMB) for review regarding the rule. We do not know for sure the timelines of the changes and if there will be any lobbying… if you are on H4 EAD, it is good to have a back-up plan for the worst case scenario.  We will keep this article updated as new information emerges.

What are your thoughts ? What do you think of new Spring 2018 regulation update ?

Reference :

Related Articles


Comments ( 2,233 )

  1. Aspirant

    I have H1B stamp in my old passport ,but I have not traveled yet on that H1. For some reason, I have to travel as dependent and have to go for H4 stamping , this will be with my new passport.Though passport differs in DS160 I have mentioned the H1B visa details. I have a plan to find another employer after traveling to US on H4 and transfer H1 to next employer and start working. My worry is if I go for H4, is there a possibility that H1B will be cancelled ? Also, if VO asks whether I am planning to work in US with my H1B , what is the safest answer so that my H1B will not be affected?Is COS applicable in my case. Appreciate quick response as my visa interview is scheduled in following days.

  2. Ramya

    When will people understand that this is not a gender issue. It’s coincidence that majority of H4s happen to be of a particular gender and particular ethnicity. By making this about gender, feminism and all other gender-specific isms, the struggles of immigrants are being diluted.

    Even among Chinese and Filipinos that suffer from backlog such gender disparity of H4 doesn’t exist. I think this speaks a lot about the lack-of-progressive-mentality among both males and females of this particular ethnicity who believe that females are second fiddles following their male companions everywhere.

    Now that they can’t fight with anything, they are giving it color of gender discrimination. Far from it.

    Should efforts be made to reduce backlog while not impacting ethnic diversity of the permanent residents? Absolutely. Should this be hijacked as gender discrimination just because a particular ethnicity considers females as lesser and followers of male companions, and as evident in practice? Absolutely not. We don’t want such backward mentality people in the US.

    Shame on those calling this gender discrimination and misogyny. Look in the mirror to find misogynists who even after knowing the pain their female partners go through still insist on staying in US and bringing them in droves to the US. If these men had an ounce of love for their partners they would have packed their bags and moved to place where both can work, instead of bringing their female partners to a place with no work rights. This phone of fight of H4-EADs by these males has less to do with supporting their females but more to do with staying in the US at all costs.

    When your female partners were feeling depressed at homes, you were busy working with no regards to whether she wants to work and what can you do to help her in realising her dreams? You were wondering how can you grow instead of how you both can grow.

    Shame on the females especially from a particular country who give this gender colour. You have more freedom here than in your home country. Be grateful. And, tell your men to start treating you as human. If US doesn’t work, ask your selfish male partner to move to Canada/Australia/Germany – all are developed economies which give you permanent residency and right to work fast. Do not make this a gender issue and dilute the struggles of immigrants of all genders, nationalities, sexual orientation and color.

    1. Ravi

      Ramya….I agree with you….I had gone through the blogs, I don’t think any one really used ‘wife’ in the place of H4 EAD holder…

      All over it is mentioned as ‘ dependent spouse’. I think only one person misunderstood and assumed ‘spouse’ means wife.

  3. desi banda

    People posting comments about how those *Indian* spouses should have their work permits snatched away from them because they *knew* they wouldn’t have a guaranteed way to work in the first place are the actual ‘misogynists’ that you hear about all the time. Next time you hear a feminist complain about misogyny and you don’t know what it’s all about- just come back here to this post and read through the comments section. Kabhi nahi sudhrenge saale.

  4. bk

    There are a few aspects that need to be considered. Talking from the people I know and who have been working so far in the US. H4 -EAD is a progressive move if it backed with tangible data that there is a marked loss in jobs of US nationals. Thinking pragmatically the impact of any law, as in any other civilized part of the world, the people who are already working under H4-EAD being stripped off the eligibility to work is a regressive legislative move. However , if the objective is to really work on the data and save US jobs, then the legislation should be prospective. Stripping people who are already working in a H4 is not only unreasonable but excessive in every manner. Prospective applicability of notifying H4 holders about the legislative intent seems far more reasonable. It is as simple as this, you do not have to hurt, displace a group of set expectations to promote what is thought to be right for the present moment, rather a law which aims to achieve the same set of expectations and objectives but in a manner not to hurt the existing matrix of expectations will be far more progressive and well received in the long run.

  5. Johan thomas

    We can all keep debating here for, and against ead. Not gonna make any difference to anyone! Stay cool till the final rule comes out, let the situation be clear. Let’s keep postings comments during comments period.
    And then, let u keep suing every step to delay the new rule if we are unable to stop it!
    Meanwhile, everyone who is eligible keep applying for ead. Even if you get it for 3 Years, and are in a doubt of what’s gonna happen 3years later during renewal, don’t worry about it for now.
    Don’t let negativity of some selfish people who are acting like gods just coz they got their green cards pull you down! As much as we all hate such people, we gotta learn to ignore them!

    1. Go4EAD

      Very sensible comment. My wife has just applied for her H4EAD extension. We filed it with my H1 extension under premium processing. Hopefully she gets her EAD extended in the next couple of weeks. And hopefully all this rocus created by Trump fades off soon.

  6. Against fake people

    Fact god save fake people . Good to see change happening . Am also waiting for merit based system to be implemented soon . No more dumb fake people should enter not just Us anywhere in the world . Did u know blore companies have started to reject such profiles the time the see it .

  7. Ravi

    Not sure why we are making this as a big deal..

    Indian spouses who traveled to US before 2015, came to this country with an assumption that they won’t be able to work until his H1B spouse gets a full Green card. If they are qualified and really want to do a job, they use to apply for H1B and then work. Only in 2015 we got this opportunity for dependents spouses and started working after 2015. It is hardly 2 years that dependent spouses started working. If they remove H4 EAD, dependent spouses who moved to US before 2015 shouldn’t blame DHS/US government. Because they never promised that they will give a work authorization for dependents.

    Indians started migrating more to US, from 1980/1990 and all these years, dependent spouses (even though they are qualified), they remained unemployed.

    The real impact is only for small set of people, who moved to US after 2015 assuming that US govt will allow the dependent spouses also to work using H4 EAD… But this is only very very small group when compared to people started moving to US from 1980/90s…

    Make sense ?

    1. SH

      Well, sorry to say; but you could not be more wrong.
      Indians who came in 80s / 90s got their GCs done within a couple of years after starting the process and most of them didn’t even have advanced degrees.
      Talking about the people who came here in early 2000s, lot of those were in hope that they will eventually get GC after 3-4 years wait; but that wait kept getting longer and longer.
      And spouses who came on H4 around start of 2015 or after, definitely expected the rule to stick.
      So this is the BIG issue.

          1. Ravi

            My point is. why only Indians are making noise.

            This is the comment I heard from one of my co-american worker… then I searched over the internet if there are any discussions going from other nationality H4 folks….didn’t find much

      1. Srikanth

        When Ind vs Aus cricket match is happening in India only you can find 99% Indians only in the stadium. Hope you can compare this with current scenario.

          1. Ravi

            Hold your tongue buddy..I manage 225 people….I dont work for a client….I manage from our own company office…

  8. Ankit

    I think this change will make “Save job USA” happy and some others who migrated here earlier and are us citizen or GC holders now. Because in reality not even single person is real American whose ancestors are from European decent. It will be fair for Red Indian only to say to go back to your country. The thing I am realizing after 10 long years of immigration ordeal, its better to leave this country and go to may be Canada or Australia. You will often hear some drug junkies or some unqualified loser saying leave and go back to your own country as if they gonna get the job you will leave behind without any skills, experience and qualification.

    1. Ravi

      I have already posted..But not able to see my older post..

      I am really not sure why we are making this as a big deal…

      Indian H1B workers (along with qualified spouses) started migrating heavily from 1990s and they all moved here with an assumption that, the dependent spouses can work only after getting a GC. (OR) the dependent spouses too can apply for H1B and start working….This was happening for all these years from 1990s to 2014/2015..

      Only in 2015, the H4 EAD came in to picture and dependent spouses started utilizing the same and started working…If they remove, H4 EAD, it is just that we are going back to the same state as 2014 and before.

      The only impact is for the families who moved here after 2015 assuming that they can utilize H4 EAD too and start working. These families won’t be able to digest as it will hurt them. But the impact is only for people who moved after 2015 (just in last 2 years) and this number will be very very very small when compared to people started moving here from 1990s..

      Make sense?

      1. Ankit

        Sir,
        this will also impact people who moved here long long time ago. I came here for f1 on 2008 then opt , H1B and waiting since 2012 for GC priority date don’t know that will ever happen. Retrogression keep happening.
        My wife’s petitions didnt get picked up for three years she has done masters from USC and then she got H4 EAD and she has 8 years of experience in India and here she just stated working and this is happening now.
        I guess the more we stay the more we will hurt our future.
        Thanks for the reply

        1. Ravi

          I can personally feel sorry for you Ankit..But here we are not talking about each individual’s issue. We need to look from a big picture…You moved here in 2008 (or anyone moved here before 2015), you (or anyone like you) never expected from 2008 to 2015 that your spouse can start work before getting GC. It just started in 2015.

          There are people who moved here after 2015 assuming that dependents too can start working using H4 EADs. They are the real impactors. May be they moved here ONLY with a assumption that both H1B and H4 can work. Otherwise, they could have stayed back in India. these are the real impacted people…but as I said earlier, these number of people are very less…

          1. Ak

            Don’t know with what assumption you are saying that this will impact people who moved here after 2015.
            In reality people who moved here after 2015 are still in f1 or in the first three years of H1B with no I 140. These folks don’t even think about H4 EAD as it’s too early for them.
            This is not just individual case almost all the people have situation like me.
            H4 EAD was the solution to a lot of problems. People were waiting for this rule for at least five or six years and now it’s going away just like that because “Save job USA” wants it to stop.

          2. Ravi

            My point is….we all lived/adjusted our life without H4 EAD, all the way from 1980/90s to 2015….

            It was one positive move in 2015 by starting H4 EAD….now they took it back and we are back to where we were in 2014..

            Not sure how many of you are aware…in UK, immigrants were able to apply for PR (equal to GC) after 5 years of stay…but in 2010, UK govt took a decision to cancel the PR.. now who ever traveled after 2010, they can’t become UK residents ever…Immigration rules bound to change….we can’t do much about it..

          3. Srikanth

            Ravi,

            Your comments and views are good in law perspect. But when comes to reality it does not work out. We did not have cell phones 20 years back. we lived happily. Can you think assuming your life without your mobile phone for 2 days. So when ever a comfort or rule comes people mindset will get adjusted to it. when you feel it is going to go off from you, the pain and pressure will be there. you cannot say no worries or adjusted.

          4. BePositive

            I know it should be called H4B holder but lets face it, in the Indian community these are mostly wives. Women who got married in 1990’s are different from women from women who got married in 2010’s. Not many people like to stay home now, its frustrating. I have seen couples divorce because their wives were not able to work and were bored out of their minds. A lot of these women are well educated and they leave their careers because of our “glorious” tradition of treating a woman’s careers as unimportant. Waiting for 8-10yrs is a very long time, unless you can spend them at home while sacrificing you career against your wishes, you shouldn’t ask anyone else to do it.

            Expressing oneself should be encouraged, it is a hard time for people on H4 EAD, they need a vent. There is no need to get annoyed. A little empathy is not going to hurt you.

      2. someone

        Ravi – I agree with you. H4 EAD never made any sense to me. If Obama wants to help H1Bs then why not give EAD directly to H1B Consultants who are skilled workers, have relevant experience and are already working in the field… rather than giving EAD to their spouses who may or may not have any skills, don’t have any work experience. I don’t understand.
        Nobody was complaining until there was no H4 EAD because everybody on H4 knew that they cant work until they get their GC.

      3. Varun

        Make sense? Absolutely not!

        When the rule was announced (not implemented) in late 2014 or early 2015 – many H4 folks who were preparing to go to Grad school to get a Master’s degree (even though they had a Master’s degree) changed their plans because of this announcement. They have been working for around 2 years and now suddenly their career will be put on hold and they will have to start from scratch again.

        When H4 dependents start working, obviously the family income increases and people might end up making significant investments like buying a house. What will happen to those families when their income reduces to half? They made those decisions because the government allowed them to work but is taking it away now.

        By the way if H4 is not allowed to work, why should L1 dependents get a EAD?

        1. JK

          Varun~ I personally feel H4 EAD should not go until country caps are removed from Green Cards. But its governments right to make whatever rule they want to for non-citizens. Non-citizens don’t have any rights. We should make our plans on our own risk. H4 EAD was always in lawsuits, after Trump coming to power there were good chances for this to happen. We are always at risks H1 extension can deny (denied for me once in past), stamping issues, getting fired. Also, for safe side husband and wife should try to have separate Visas. Going to college to get F1 was always better that relying on dependent visa work permit. If you are good you can finish Masters in 1 year, then you are free bird with 12+17 months of OPT EAD with three attempts of H1 lottery where you have a special Masters quota (90% with make it in 3 attempts).
          L1 is considered to be highly skilled visa so some special preference is given. Anyways, L1 can’t be your final visa if you want to stay in US for long, L1 has a fixed life 6-7 years. H1 is the only immortal visa once you have I140 approved.

          1. Varun

            H4 EAD is only for spouses of people who have an approved I140. Which means that these people will eventually get a green card and will be authorized to work. But if they take away H4EAD for the I140 approved folks, would the eventual work authorization through green card be super helpful given that they spend the prime of their careers/life not allowed to working?

            I agree that there is always a risk so people should make plans accordingly. The same argument applies to everyone, even the people who say that they lost their jobs because of immigrants (although they lost their jobs to automation, not to people of a certain nationality). There was always a risk that they could loose their jobs, then why the lawsuit?

            Anyhow, people should be able to trust the government’s word to a certain degree. If the administration changes its opinion every year, it is not going to help anyone.

          2. Varun

            L1 is not considered higher skilled compared to H1. Also not everyone can be on L1. Conaider someone who did their Masters from US. They worked in US only after their school and never worked outside US so L1 is not an option. Also other than the requirement of working sometime outside the US, there is no higher skill bar for L1

        2. Ravi

          you answer itself gives more clarity.. You said, people were trying to go to school (2014/2015) for Masters degree… They decided to invest money/time to get a work permit using OPT EAD and then take it from there….

          Fortunately, Obama Govt brought in H4 EAD and they changed their plan, started working directly….and for 2 years they were able to save some money..

          2015 Immigration rule was brought in as a favor to us
          2017/2018 immigration rule may be against us..

          We can always go back to what we planned earlier (Masters), start them now again..whats a difference…we atleast have 2 years of salary saved to invest in Masters fees..

          We all came from a country where bigger decisions are taken with in one day….like cancelling 500/1000 Rs notes…it initially had impacted lot of small business people….but we get along and tune us for new systems and grow from there..

          1. Varun

            There is no use/need to mention unrelated facts like cancelation of notes in India. Of course when push comes to shove people take extreme steps like doing a Master degree again in a field that you already have a Masters degree in.

            Point is, why? If all H4 EAD holders go to schools and get a Master’s degree and enter the workforce with an H1B, will it not hurt the American job market then (assuming it is hurting now, which has no supporting data)

          2. Ravi

            Why not bring examples…

            I was referring to Govt decisions. Govt only printed 500/1000 rs notes earlier and they are in use for very very long period..they took a decision to cancel..it hurts some people…some may get benefited… But Govt is taking that decision for a reason..

            In the same way, US Govt can also take their own decision..
            Lot of people protested against PM Modi against Rs notes. If we obey to Govt decisions in our own country where we have citinzenship, why can’t we obey the decision in other country where we we don’t have any say..

          3. Varun

            Nobody is saying that we are not going to obey (unless you want to end up in jail). People will of course obey and do what is legal at any given point of time. Does that mean that we should not voice our opinion? It is exactly because of this attitude (not speaking up) that Indian community as a whole has never been able to influence any major policy in its favor.

            H4 EAD makes total sense to me. Even if it was not directly benefitting me I would have supported it.

            Rules are there for a reason, that is to make the life of the maximum number of people smooth. If we stay quiet and say nothing (because we obeyed the currency ban :)) the US lawmakers will not even know how many lives will this rule affect.

            It is important to hear both sides of the story, which can not be heard if the people who are affected don’t say anything

          4. Ravi

            My point is if we can’t voice out in our own country…

            what is the point in voicing here ?? when we are only considered as temp workers…

            My point is….H4 EAD is just there only for 2 years…we lived without it for so many years…

            forget about it, make new plans and go forward…

          5. Scott

            @Varun,
            –US lawmakers will not even know how many lives will this rule affect.—
            The common misconception is that somehow the US lawmakers should consider temporary worker’s grievances and not that of their own citizens. The lawmakers are listening and making a correction to the mistake the earlier administration made, it so happens YOU don’t like the change they are making. This change affects many citizens positively, have you thought about that? Remeber you here as a temp worker. You are here to work, nothing else!

  9. Mishra

    This is the TRUTH and Hard Truth. Muslims pray towards MECCA during their Prayers. In India, People from South Pray towards America, People from Punjab (PENDUS) pray towards Canada, People from Gujarat pray towards UK.

    It is a cultural mindset that the best thing to achieve status is migrate to these countries. Hopefully these new laws by Trump will get some sense into us Indians. Make your own country Great and Techie Jobs are not the most sought after anymore. Soon, techie will suffer the same problems as Oil and Gas professionals who have no jobs.

    Indians are living in a bubble and Americans are also living in a bubble that as soon as Immigrants will leave they will get better jobs. You see both will be disappointed as companies will just move jobs abroad.

    1. Ashish

      No, the truth is that we voted in droves for Trump because we thought he was going to come after the Muslims and kick them all out while giving us more jobs and visas. Despite most Indian Americans being Democrat we still went along and voted Trump. It is coming to bite us on our back sides. But I agree, there will be disappointments all around once the reality hits all the parties as to where the jobs are going.

      1. Mishra

        Is not Trump’s fault, it’s American voters / people come to bite us, because we are taking their jobs and lowering the wages, hurting economics.

    2. Amanda

      Well said mish. First of all all EAD , or any visa holder it’s not your country. We have full Right to revoke working right of visa holders. Our country did call visa holder you people filed visa petition right? So go to wherever you came from. I am not saying this USA president is saying this.we do not need more immigrants please. Next target is to keep brightest visa holders not just some techie.

  10. Listener

    The main reason we migrated to this country was because we realized that the quality of life here was better, the local residents were people of high quality, integrity and were humane. I think every human being has a right to apply for a citizenship in this country and that should never stop. There is a vetting process in place that takes into consideration skills and background of these applicants. I think there should also be some kind of evaluation of traits and culture. Many of the recent GC holders as I see in the conversations below seem to be selfish trashbags saying I want it all and you newcomers deserve nothing….doesnt work that way sirs! You have to accommodate these new applicants the way we accommodated you and the locals then had accommodated us!

    1. Trump Supporter

      Yes, quality of life is better here but very soon it will be like any other third world country because people living here will define the culture and the way every year thousands of Indians and Chinese are migrating here, very soon US will be like India and China. Full of corruption like India, where women will not feel safe when walking on street.

  11. Listener

    Its quite shameful watching the arrogant behaviour of recent immigrants who have just received their green cards..most of whom are the average Joes with no special skills..flops in their home country, made it to US on time to grab a GC. Now they mock the newer applicants..Shame on you crabs…I am afraid its is actually the children of such people and their future generations that will deplete this great country of its core values.. I came to this country in 1987…had a much better quality of immigrants at that time..

    1. Mishra

      It’s not because of your kind of people arrogant, it’s because of competition in job mkt. Removing H4 EAD will give more chance to competent H1b and to US citizens. Sorry it’s that crucial we all try to survive.

  12. Employer

    I can see both sides. First, I run a Artificial Intelligence/Machine Learning team for a 5B dollar company (won’t tell the name). Among 50% of my best and the brightest team are from India. Some are H4EADs. I find it extremely difficult to hire talented people. We hire for talent and it’s that simple. If this H4EAD goes away, let me tell you, The land of immigrants will take a huge step back in terms of innovation.

    What the politicians are not understanding is it’s not the H1/H4s taking the jobs. Its the automation. My team developed a product that automates the hell out of some traditional manual work – we saved about 10MM a year just in my company and as a result we let go 10% of the work force.

    Revoking H4EAD is clearly a political move which adds to long term value to the country.

    I feel sorry for the US. This move will only defer the inevitable which is what the administration cares.

    1. Vinay

      If they are the best and the brightest why have they not been able to get permanent residency quickly? The last time I checked the best and brightest belong to EB1 category and get permanent residency within a year or two – even those born in India or China.

      Are we sure in qualifying every MS/MBA grad or one with 5+ years of experience who works in ML/AI as best and brightest? Hardly.

      We can pat ourselves saying EB2 and EB3 are also best and brightest just to feel good but there is a reason why they’re in EB2/EB3 and not in EB1. There is also a reason why time for EB1 is shorter than EB2/EB3. If an employer and attorney think of you as best and the brightest, they will do everything to get you in EB1. The US is very generous when it comes to the real best and brightest folks. Perhaps we should revisit the definition of the best and the brightest. If someone tells me that all under EB2/EB3/H4-EAD are best and brightest, I see that as lowering the bar.

    2. Amanda

      Lol mr employer why do not you hire student from Ivy League. Answer you can not get cheap labor right? Lol 5 billion Zimbabwe dollar right ? I think your company value is 5 billions Zimbabwe dollars

      1. Amanda ka pappa

        Shut up troll, by your poor English it’s extremely easy to figure out that you are not a native American so shove it, please.

    3. Trumpie

      “Huge step back in innovation if H4 READ is revoked” ???

      Are you saying that there was a huge step forward in innovation since 2015 due to H4 EAD that will be stifled due to this move? Can you name a few of those huge steps forward? I am all ears.

      1. trumpie chya bappa

        ‘I’m all ears’ hahaha, doesn’t get more desi than that wannabe, Gora banne ki koshish karne lag gaya kabootar bc haha, what a loser.

  13. Mark

    I have done masters in US and I am on h1b visa I get 30k$ PA working as developer in java technology and my spouse on h4 visa gets 40k $ PA .If h4 visa is revoked is it better to apply for h1b visa or f1 visa.

    1. Jill

      Pity on you,what the hell you are doing in USA with just 30k annual pay?

      You would get better salary in infia.BTW how come USA allowed you to file petition they have minimum as 65k.probably you misinterpreted the numbers .

      Best is throw your degree and go back home

    2. VDesi

      This is why an average person in America does not like all the visas given out like candy. $40k for programmer, it’s called a race to the bottom.

    1. AZ

      Mishra jk
      You are such a looser . You spend time on this page posting shit and you want your employer to pay you more for all the shir you have.
      If i were your employer, i would have threw you out of company for wasting your time on the shit to.happen and not working on your skills.

      You are worth 1k and you dont even deserve to work for free. These bloody rules keeps changing and it would hurt your kids future too. Be careful.

      1. Mishra

        The thing hai, mujhe toh mera gc mil Gaya hai na. Toh h4 EAD should be revoked. Coz I am a bhaiyya, trained to not give f***s about people right since my childhood! My family can work, get money, get everything.
        I love seeing bad things happen to others and I keep moving ahead and ahead in my life. Hahhhahhah

        1. chaturvedi ji

          kisko chu bana rahe ho mishraji. life mein kuchh achieve nahi kiya, boss roz aapki leta hai, chaar baar fire ho chuke ho. Yaha aake frustration nikaalne ka matlab ‘I’m moving ahead in life’ nahi hai.

  14. Ajay

    People lament about killing dreams of H4s. No one has asked them to come here, it is a well thought out choice made. You knew the rules of the game and made an informed decision. And, if career is so important then it’s time for H4s and their partner H1Bs to sit, talk and come to a workable solution on where both can be happy, assuming both are career oriented. I have seen many couples taking pragmatic calls. It just depends on how badly one wants to live in US even at the expense of their self-respect and at the expense of their partner’s self-worth. Sadly, we Indians, who tout so much of family values, fare very badly in this space.

    We talk about ‘Oh! We have been here so long, it’s hard to move.’ Big deal! Millions have done this in past and millions will do so in future. It requires one to be enterprising.

    When I was pushed against the wall, I was feeling helpless and scared what will future be and how I will survive outside of US, I made an informed decision to start a business by leaving US. Two years were painful but I got traction and now back in the US on a green card. US was built by immigrants who were enterprising. In hindsight not winning the H1B lottery and being on H4 was the best thing that happened to me.

    On the path to become green card holder is not exactly same as being a Permanent Resident, hence not all rights of PRs and citizens can be provided.

    If the govt starts thinking about those that are not PR/citizens yet then what are they doing to make life easier of those who voted for them?

  15. SH

    I don’t think some of the haters even understand the reason behind H4-EAD.
    First of all, it’s only applicable to spouses of H1Bs who have approved I-140 and gonna wait in queue for GC for next 40-50 years. That’s mainly Indians in EB2. It’s not fair on them when people from other countries who are less qualified than them get GC and their spouses get to work. With haters’ logic, those spouses are also taking job away from US citizens, right?

    1. Mishra

      SH you are talking nonsense . If everyone who is waiting for GC should get EAD, then there will be few million people every year getting EAD coming to here to work while they are waiting.
      do you think American will buy you logic ? LOL, bunch of moron here

      1. MEET antani

        Mishra Ji even guys on valid H1 if not good don’t get jobs. People are talking as if having a visa is guarantee to get a job. If that is the case then there won’t be anyone without job.
        Where is the data to show what percentage of H4EAD actually got full time job or started doing business. Not even 10% simply cause I140 comes at least several years after landing in US and H4 were out of job market for that long. It is not easy to get job simply cause you have an EAD.
        If H4 EAD is gone then even L1 dependents and F1 dependents job rules should change as well.
        Employers will always prefer hardworking employees those who are willing to trave l , relocate and do more in less money. It is simple business sense.
        Most of the locals who cry losing jobs don’t even qualify for the job.
        Fake C V is a menace but that can always be tackled with background verification.

        1. Mishra

          Every EAD already got job either in IT or low end retail jobs etc. we cannot take 100k of EAD so far or 800k EAD in next 10 years. Revoking all of these spouse’s EAD is a must

        2. Sunny

          F1 dependents cannot work. Dont you know this. I dont understand this, a h1b is employer dependent but h4 ead is not employer dependent. A h1b cannot have business on his name as it is a work visa why can a h4 ead start business. Why there is lot of previlage for h4 ead when comparef to h1b. Correct me if i am wrong

    2. Ashish

      I don’t know what to say about the revoking of this rule. We were so happy to be voting Trump because he was going to be anti Muslim. Despite most Indian Americans being Democrats we still went ahead and voted Trump. I guess we had it coming. I suppose this teaches us a few lessons to stand up for our interests. I don’t know how much the local congressmen can help but it’s certainly worth a try to reach out to them. I suggest using the links posted in some of the comments below. Let’s make our case people.

  16. DreamforGC

    I brought up my two kids for 8 years and sat at home twiddling my thumbs with a bachelors in computer science and U.S. masters degree. When I got my H4EAD I applied for positions and got hired with a month, as there was a shortage of people with my skills in computer science and machine learning. My company has benefitted tremendously from my experience and it also has driven the local economy by my personal spending in the local economy. Now I’m planning to establish my own start-up, and I got the news yesterday about the new H4 rule to be abolished soon. It stopped me short in my tracks . We have been waiting for 8 years in the green card backlog now. We legal immigrants are good for the economy, we contribute to taxes, local economy, start new businesses that hire Americans and spur innovation.

    I plan on calling my local congressman, who has already cosponsored HR392, to bring this legislation to a vote. Please join “Immigration Voice” platform on telegram. Just google. It’s time for the desi junta to wake up and take matters in your own hands. If the DACA kids can do it we can do it too. Donate to our cause on Immigration Voice dot org website. Talk to your neighbours about the 70 year long backlog, talk to your colleagues. It is the scumbag companies like Microsoft, Apple and Google that do not want to see this backlog end, as they will lose their indentured high skilled slaves.

    FIGHT FOR YOURSELF AND FOR YOUR FAMILY.

    1. Mishra

      It’s useless. The point is this group of H4 EAD will grow 70k each year, and most most of them are incompetent for IT jobs. They are taking American jobs, H1b’s job by faking resumes and experience. Trump’s admin knows about it, it’s about America First

      1. Raj

        MISHRA : If u r from shitty USM, I come from UCLA. So what? I come from top 10 universities and that doesn;t mean I am great and u r pedophile. Its your thinking, knowledge that matters. I can only think of you with a prostitute mindset . The fake resume thing has been there from 2000’s ( donno before that as I came in 2002). So we have amassed 17 yrs of fake resumes, profiles till today where as H4 EAD came in 2015. So wh has the highest no of fake profiles…First few yrs of H1’s & OPT’s and I know u are one of them. Majority of them are not even into IT! Gone are those days of telephonic IV. Now all are F2F IV’s and even though u have fake profile, u are easily caught by the way u perform in IV. By luck if you go through, we can weed out in your first few months which I did as I recruit contractors in my firm and all are fake. I even hired H4 recently and she genuinely kept gap of 3 yrs without any faking like u do to get high pay. We are pretty impressed with her work and also sponsoring H1B this year. Screening, background check is the same for every one and it doesnt change based on visa you have. So know the ABC’s of recruiting before generalizing everything. At the end of day, they are scrapping H4 EAD not because of fake resumes, it;s because Jeff sessions is against it even before its implementaion and they want to scrap all rules of Obama’s. There is no valid proof that H4’s are taking American jobs and that’s the reason the lower court cancelled it on baseless allegations. Its only because of Jeff that the DHS prepared rule to end it..At the end of the day, pedophiles will be kicked out of this country once they implement new rules of H1 though you pretend u are citizen.

        1. Mishra

          Raj you guys stilll don’t get it: we cannot accept any more foreign worker. There will be at least 800k H4 in next 10 years. With most of these incompetent immigrants flooding to here, our wage would be much lower. Our kids’ future would be hopeless etc. Enough to say.
          Bottom line is H4 EAD violates Hire American, American First rule.

          1. FightMe

            Understood.. you are saying we should let our hopes into ditch to keep your hopes alive.. such an illogical theory.. grow up.. don’t wait for the Apple to fall on your plate and don’t forget that what century you are living in.. I see how frustrated you are with your employer.. go work on your skills to get the highest pay.. STOP blaming others as a reason for your incapability..

          2. Mishra

            America First, We make decisions. You Indian taking our jobs and still greedy begging for more. Your H1b husbands already support you and family. H4 housewife stay home or go home. Don’t get suffered in our country hurting our economic.
            LOL

          3. FightMe

            You keep on chanting the same.. your employer will send you back home with a big Ladoo.. you will come to reality on that day..

      2. Johan thomas

        Mr Mishra, how about keeping EAD around with more regulations ? I mean put yourself down in position of someone on EAD, who got right to work, and now it being completely revoked vs making stricter rules and laws, and dhs keeping an eye out on our qualifications, and the jobs we get? To avoid any frauds that all from happening?

    2. Ajay

      What a drivel and myth that backlog is for 70 years. And unimaginable to call these companies scummbag which has helped tens of thousands greencard.

      As much as I support H4-EAD they are bringing wages down which should not be supported. For every one or two H4s earning $200k there are many that earn less than $60k. And depressing wages must be stopped at all costs

      1. Raj

        Buddy, I just laugh at what u think. Do u think researcher post doc or medical resident gets beyond 60k? That’s the pay they get and it’s standard pay irrespective of being on visa or gc. Don’t say that H4s are lowering the pay, its witch Indian company’s that are doing it. The vendors are minting the money and even h4 is removed they will push it on opt.

    3. Swati

      Alright, i opened a new business on H4EAD and spent $200K into it , What do i do now? Close the shop and go back to where it all started. I cant believe hypocrites supporting this judgement, calling it’s taking away jobs etc etc. I have employed 1 american full time and 3 mexicans, no body talks about them because they eventually will find something but what about me?

      1. Mishra

        You case is extreme, we are dealing with 100k H4EAD so far or one million in 10 yrs. do you think Trump’s people would allow H4 EAD taking our jobs, hurting wages. Wake up, American First.

      2. Vinay

        You have faster way to get PR than others, speak with an attorney.

        And not all H4-EADs are same. Those who show US values if starting a small sustainable business then they must be allowed to work, not wage depressing folks who undercut market wages.

    4. Jeff vangalapudi

      Totally with you. It’s good to here that there’s more positive people just like I am. We are doing everything legally, by the book in this country. So we can’t take this lying down. For whoever thinks this is end of EAD, it’s not. We will make sure it’s months and months, slow this regulation down with lawsuit every step. Not because we have to make a point. It’s because we are in the right!
      SO TO ALL THE PEOPLE AFFECTED BY EAD, MAKE SURE WE ALL CONTACT STATESMEN, SENATORS, CONGRESSMEN, AND STOP THIS FROM GOING AWAY.
      ALSO, WE GOTTA SUBMIT AS MANY COMMENTS AS WE CAN. 50k minimum. 1 million if we all ask our every family member in US to submit positive comments for EAD.
      They got to record the comment and response by comment by comment basis. So it should significantly slow down the process.
      And if you are on h4 EAD, and work for companies like google, Microsoft etc, you guys are golden! Ask your employers to file comments as well.
      With all this, we also got immigration voice and AILA on our side.
      Together, we can do wonders! Not the time to be sad. Time to get it done.

    5. Trumpie

      Before you sat at home twiddling your thumbs, you had made a conscious decision to apply for a H4 DEPENDENT visa that very clearly states that you cannot work. Did you forget that decision?

      1. Johan thomas

        Nope. We dnit move here till h4 EAD regulation was passed. I know, you will keep arguing about how it was still wrong of us to move based on this regulation, but that’s your opinion(which of course is your right to have one). I think differently. They should have some consideration towards this fact, that we moved here, for the professions they need here, and we get our standard of living that we dream of, and freedom to work, as EAD was passed by then. So now to take it away from people who moved here based on the situation back then, they shouldn’t change it for most.
        There should be stricter rules and limitations on ead(I mean freedom to work anywhere, which even the primary h1b holder doesn’t have is excessive). But revoking it completely, and taking away from people who planned their lives around this work permit is wrong.

        1. Tam

          Rules change all the times, especially for temporary workers. Deal with it. Think about the people who lost their jobs to cheap labor. You are not better than any one of them.

  17. VDesi

    If you can afford it, spend $500k and get green card in 6 months using eb5. It’s not a fee, but an investment with good possibilities of return of principal and appreciation.

  18. G3

    H4 EAD was my life savior.. for a dreamer like me who wanted to be independent, explore and achieve this news is so crumbling.. we dependents were waiting for a long time in the queue for this golden opportunity to prove ourselves..we dependents are longing for some respect from our families, children to show them that we are very much capable.. we wanted to be a best example for our kids..trashing my 11 years experience in my field of interest for nothing but to sit idle and get depressed at home is like killing my thoughts, dreams and much more my independency to live..
    What do you expect from all these talented dependents to do.. Should we sacrifice all our dreams for being a dependent of an h1b holder.. or should an h1b holder not choose to live with his family to pursue his deeds or do you think it is that easy to live in this country with 1 salary with the cost of living here..totally it’s a cruelty to remove this rule.. we are not taking the opportunity of anyone else.. for any job position the employer is doing the necessary screening steps.. do you think with fake resumes the candidate will be able to get through the screening processes or by chance if they got placed do you think they will be able to secure that position for a long time.. impossible.. only the real talent gets the opportunity.. there are numerous positions in the market that are yet to be filled.. if you are really talented you will get your place.. fight with us rather than being a coward.. it’s really frustrating.. don’t be our dream killers..we kindly request you to let us live a normal independent respected life as we wished.. please do not revoke h4 ead..

    1. rr

      when a person getting married don’t they know that they cannot work in US then why they say all reasons for working its all drama of greedy man. Initially they want to come to us then argue for rights etc… its all greed talent can survive anywhere we can see millionaires in India also. Till we are citizen of US we should abide by US laws whatever it gives as you came to US not US called you If Africa calls you will go no right?

    2. Ajay

      People lament about killing dreams of H4s. No one has asked them to come here, it is a well thought out choice made. You knew the rules of the game and made an informed decision. And, if career is some important then it’s time for H4s and their partner H1Bs to sit, talk and come to a workable solution on where both can be happy, assuming both are career oriented. I have seen many couples taking pragmatic calls. It just depends on how badly one wants to live in US even at the expense of their self-respect and at the expense of their partner’s self-worth. Sadly, we Indians, who tout so much of family values, fare very badly in this space.

      On the path to become green card holder is not exactly same as being a Permanent Resident, hence not all rights of PRs and citizens can be provided.

      If the govt starts thinking about those that are not PR/citizens yet then what are they doing to make life easier of those who voted for them?

    3. AZ

      I second this. You are so like me. It’s so nerve wracking when someone generalizes about fake resumes nd fake talent.

      Even if the resume is fake, who the heck on this earth can survive the screenprocess and the 5 rounds of interview with different process. One cannot fake the in person interview.

      This is very cruel and i pity those people who are wwaiting for the h4 repeal rather than working on their skills and getti g their 1000k dream salary

        1. ss

          Just because u r not efficient or skilled enough u cant say like this.. u r among those who cant grow without pulling other down.. SHAME on u

    4. Tam

      The only suggestion for the people complaining about H4 EAD is to slap your spouse who is on H1 as hard as you can, for keeping you enslaved for all these years. You could have used your “talents” and be productive in India where you are eligible to work. It is because your spouse’s lack of consideration for your ambitions you are in the situation you are today, it not because of the H4 EAD. If you are even slightly serious about using your skills to be productive, move right now, to a place where you can work. H4 EAD is a slap in American worker’s face. It has nothing to do with your talents, it takes opportunities away from Americans.

  19. Maryam

    So far approximately 100k EADs are issued. How many of H4 EADs actually got full time jobs which is paying them good ? How may jobs were displayed cause of H4 EADs ? There is no actual data available anywhere to show H4 EAD is real threat to American Jobs and still someone decided to go after law abiding visa holders who are paying taxes and contributing to economy. It is a known fact that school ratings improve wherever Indians live as their kids do well in studies and score well in standardized tests which in turn helps to increase property values in that school district.
    Indians are easy targets and no one will come to their rescue to at least debate n facts.

    1. Tam

      H4 affects everyone, not just Indians. Know your facts. Sure, Indians are complaining the most. Indian kids are getting a FREE American education, so there is a mutual benefit, which you forgot to mention. Now, don’t say you are paying taxes, so is everyone else. Property values fall as Indians move in, as no one else wants to live there.

  20. Amanda Hawkins

    This is great news. Thanks to trump govt for this decision. Most of h4 ead holders use fake resume to get Job. They do not even have masters from USA.fake resume and proxy interviews are taking valuable jobs.hopefully H1B new rules will implement soon raise wage level to 100k. Great work trump govt keep it up.

    1. Divya

      I worked with different top tier companies in India for 8 years with some exposure to work in South Africa. I was at a very good phase of my career when I had to leave my career behind to join my husband in USA. I heard that if a person is talented than he/she can flourish in USA. This thought made me to make such pathetic decision to come USA. This American dream makes me a dependent person whose freedom of earning has been snatched. Instead, It has gifted me depression and several other medical issues. I have been waiting for my EAD for last three years, and now once I received it, I have to throw this dream of independence in trash again.
      Even-though we are qualified and experienced enough to take a responsible job in USA, we have been forced to sit at home. This is cruelty. H4 dependents are not taking any once job but giving a competitive platform. We are much educated and experienced spouses of H1 visa holders and we can together make America great again. Revoking H4 EAD is simply a cruelty with so many much educated and highly experienced professionals.

          1. Srinivasan

            O’ Proud Defender of the Desi Rights!

            Thy name we shall chant. Our humble prayers for you to keep vigorously typing on your keyboard from the comfort of your 4 bedroom home!

            Pray you burn like the shining star you are!

        1. Amanda

          I am alumni of USM and not a fake name. None of h4 ead has to pay student loan. Fist of all they use fake resume. Secondly they are from some stupid college. If fee in American college would be affordable they we will not have seen single visa holder in my country. Anyway bye bye now . Hire American and buy American

          1. Listener

            Which country did your parents or grandparents immigrate to US from? You want to draw the border after your family conveniently stepped into the country..Not fair is it?

      1. Trumpie

        You had made a conscious decision to apply for a H4 DEPENDENT visa that very clearly states that you cannot work. Did you forget that decision? You are making it look like the US government forced you to come to their country. If a job was so important to you, why even apply for a DEPENDENT visa.

        Thousands of immigrants (after marriage) come as students or try their luck with H1. You chose to apply for H4 and you are blaming the country for it?

        1. Divya

          Hi,

          Thanks for your kind words.
          I knew very well about H4 visa and its limitations. I have double Masters degree in Computer Science and one from USA. You have correctly mentioned that try ur luck with H1.
          Unfortunately my luck is not in my favor. But here I would like to ask a simple question. Suppose, I got my H1 in lottery.
          In that case, am I not taking an american job? I am not blaming anyone for anything.I just wanted to mention that earning is a basic right of a person and we have potential to serve for ds country dn why not get EAD?

    2. M

      I really dunno whats a fake resume? How can you answer interviews with fake resume? Its all technical positions. But transitioning into a new role is different. You can do that at anytime without any issues. You can take a network training and become a NOC. you can take certification courses and start at base levels.

      I think Indians do have a talent with computers which is the future now . Automation, cloud, Devops are all in trend and the Indian Techs do that job. How does this take away others job? I havent seen people from other countries eve try that. I have seen prople in management (lower level) but not even trying to be technical.

      A valid argument would be , do not allow immigrants to take Management positions which are not techy and could be very well done by the local people. But companies are moving to a technical/Hands on Manager which i could say has possible reasoning.

      But telling Indians taking tech jobs from people makes me roll and laugh. Its not at all true.

      1. Tam

        You have a myopic view of the IT market. Americans gave up on tech jobs, as we cannot work for the low salaries like most visa holders do. That is the reason you don’t see many natives working in IT. It will take a while to undo the damage caused by Indian techies. Just because you see Indian working in the latest technologies, does not mean they are making top dollars.

        1. HatersWillHate

          Sorry Tam
          You must be really really rich. I and other tech people on H1B are happy with our low paying jobs IF according to you $150k – $300k range is considered as LOW. Americans can keep their $8 / hour HIGH paying jobs in burger king . We definitely won’t compete for that as we lack skills for SUCH HIGH paying jobs

          1. TAM

            There is no end to your arrogance . ONLY H1s make 150 to 300k and all Americans make $8? I have no words for your ignorance. I can guarantee you less than 5% H1s are in the bracket you mentioned. Most of they make less thank 100k at best.

    3. Barath

      Don’t bluntly generalize things, know the facts, use your brain.
      How many US-citizen employees here have Masters? American’s hardly have Masters in their qualification.
      Fake resume and proxy interview? – Yes, some of them do that, NOT ALL. Do you think software job is that easy to survive by faking their skillset? They get fired in no time if they don’t demonstrate their skills in jobs.
      There’s huge lack of skillset among americans. American government should take steps to reduce university fee for americans and encourage people here towards STEM jobs. Once the skillset grows then apparently companies recruit americans over non-us citizens.

    4. Barath

      Don’t bluntly generalize things, know the facts, use your brain.
      How many US-citizen employees here have Masters? American’s hardly have Masters in their qualification.
      Fake resume and proxy interview? – Yes, some of them do that, NOT ALL. Do you think software job is that easy to survive by faking their skillset? They get fired in no time if they don’t demonstrate their skills in jobs.
      There’s huge lack of skillset among americans. American government should take steps to reduce university fee for americans and encourage people here towards STEM jobs. Once the skillset grows then apparently companies recruit americans over non-us citizens.

      1. Amanda

        Lol huge lack of talent . Because of corrupt government fee of college is unaffordable. What rank of college where you did your studies in India . Another how much money you pay for your B.S. whole course 5000 usd. People bribe college official in India to get admission. What else you want to know about h4ead cheaters from me. Anyway now it is banned and H1B will be made difficult. Why you are so concern about Usa . R u USA citizen or gc holder no. You see Usa as a cash cow but thanks to trump no more visa abuse.

  21. HadEnough

    I did my Masters from CMU and then worked for a top tech company for 3 years. Applied H1B for 4 consecutive years in 36 months of OPT (one attempt was after I got the offer and before the job started and hence 4 attempts) Never got picked in lottery. I had a better job than my husband, then lost it because of the stupid lottery. Now we were hoping H4 EAD helps me resurrect my career but that also seems to be fading slowly. I feel like leaving USA gracefully at this point seems like the right thing to do. Here, whole life is about H1/H4 and the damn EB2 green card queue they say is 20 plus years now. There is more to life than stupid immigration issues . USA might have a lot of money and opportunities , but all this comes at the cost of peace of mind. Good luck to all hopefuls !

    1. Payal Sahani

      Absolutely. I am tired. What kind of life is this? Always worrying about the next visa status. I understand that we are immigrating to another country, so don’t expect a red carpet. But the amount of paperwork, interviews, lotteries etc. really breaks you inside. We are well educated, smart and driven people. In spite of that, to always live in the fear of rejection/deportation is soul breaking.

      US ends up pardoning and granting citizenship of illegal immigrants/border crossers every now and then. But it is easy to go after well documented high skilled legal immigrants. It serves their political agenda and provides an outlet for conservative Americans to express their anti-immigration stand.

      This is not a life we deserve. We work hard not just for ourselves, but also for the success of the American companies.

  22. Harry

    Guys I’m also on H4 EAD and recently got a good job but don’t lose hope and instead call your congressmen and request for their help. Just posting blogs will not help, start calling them today and join “Immigration voice” on facebook they are doing so much for us already by filing a motion against this case they were already successful in atleast delaying the decision. I only want to say do something, call congressmen, show they how it will damage you and your life. Join “Immigration voice” and show if you will get losses and how. For ex: if you have opened up some business on this visa and hired American people or citizens. Show them that americans will lose their job

    1. SH

      Good point.
      Can you (and anyone else) post links to these forums / groups / pages, where our voice could be heard and would mean something. We should try to kill this unjust insanity before it takes effect.

    2. TS

      I hope H1 EAD survives!
      Just shifted here last month. Do not intend to go back anytime soon. Waited for the work authorization for 5 years now. Guys, please let’s come together and do something about this.

      1. Harry

        Find it here , I’ve already call almost 15 times to support HR 392 bill , please do something else things will go out of our hands :-

        https://www.house.gov/representatives/find-your-representative

  23. VDesi

    Let’s see. America makes rules and changes rules as per their needs. Sometimes you get GC, sometimes you don’t. Nothing was guaranteed, no one forced you to come here or is forcing you to stay here. Some of the ungratefulnees display by genorisity of America is appalling.
    Finally, the only safe way left to come to America is EB-5. Everything else is a waste of money, especially F-1.

    1. desi banda

      You have no clue what this is about, do you? EADs were given to spouses of H1 holders who already have an approved I-140, it means they are in line for a residentship which is in accordance with the current rule for L2 visa holders. Giving an opportunity to work to those people and then snatching it away will obviously make people mad but apologists like you hold others at such high standards that no society can live up to it. If you can’t help then at least don’t sit there and judge others, and I’m pretty sure you would not be giving any of your gyaan here if you yourself or your wife/husband was going to have their EAD revoked by this new atrocity that the Trumpet administration came up with.

      1. VDesi

        You really should get even with the Trump Administration by leaving USA. See how badly they will beg you to come back.

        Rules and laws change. Get mad, jump up and down, make noise, write letters, make comments, not much will change but will make you feel better. Don’t forget to thank America on the opportunities you were given.

        1. Ank

          Bro, this is about moral ethics and about being right and wrong and not about politics.No one is denying the fact that US government cannot change laws.But this is not how globalization works where everything thing is a resource .What is happening today is pure protectionism.By this logic other countries should stop doing business with US companies.When India does something like this then US goes crying in front of WTO (example the Solar dispute).
          Anyways, you are correct in saying that immigrants have no rights.Whatever happens has to be accepted.

          1. VDesi

            Globalization applies to goods not jobs. I can buy a solar panel from USA or import from China, whichever I want. I can’t import a Nigerian programmer just because he is cheaper than an American.

        2. desi banda

          Oh yeah people should just uproot their families and lives and leave. They shouldn’t even protest for such unfair and mean spirited efforts which directly affect their lives. Why don’t you go back right now man, I’m sure they don’t want you anymore than they want us. Thank America and pack your bags- practice what you preach.

  24. ssn

    H4 EAD is the only thing that kept me hopeful of a solution to my dilemma in US. I have been away from my wife since 2 yrs now, waiting for my I140 to be approved so that my wife can work here and i can finally live a normal life in US, but based on this news i dont think there is any hope left for new H4 EADs. Life hits you in unique ways everday!! You just have to take it in stride and prepare for the next shock i guess!!

    1. SH

      File it. Just in case, if this rule doesn’t go thru, you will be benefited. And even if this goes thru, it’ll still take some time to take effect. If you get approved EAD before that, there is a chance that your wife will get to work atleast for a few months.

    2. administrator
      Kumar

      Deep,
      You should file it. Nothing changes as of today. It will take months for this current process to go through. Also, once H4 EAD given, even if they remove in worst case, they usually will give more time to the current EADs to extend and slowly exit so it has less impact for businesses.

  25. RD

    I’m on H4 EAD because I applied for H1B for 3 times and didn’t get into the lottery at all! If this could at least be delayed, I hope I could at least try H1B for a 4th time 🙁

    This is unfair. Companies always tend to hire Americans first because sponsorship is expensive. We are actually more expensive than those losers who can’t win even so much advantage.

    1. AZ

      I am in the same boat. Applied for H1 for 2 times, did not get picked in the lottery. So, I have to do Master’s without any scholarship. When I finally started working, they are revoking H4 EAD which sounds so insane.

      I paid for this country so that I can work and live my dream. But now, it’s all over.

      Let’s come together, raise our voices and fight for ourselves and for our families. Let’s make sure we get at least 50k comments

      1. Nv

        First of all u didnt pay for this country. U paid 4 urself. 2nd because of ead people who directly come from other countries get work easily due to less paper work but a person who has studied in usa and wirks day n night doenst get job just because company doesnt wanna file h1 nd get into paper work process.

        1. AZ

          If you are not from an ‘OTHER COUNTRY’ like me,why do you need a h1?

          If you have studied day nd night, i did too but why do you think you are more elegible than me?

          It’s not the paper work. It’s your knowledge determination and hardwork. If you crack the interview, and if the organizatio s think that you are eligible than everyone, they would file h1 for you.

          Rather than blaming h4 spouses, blame yourself

          1. Srinivasan

            Hahahaha…so hilarious watching desis turn on each other in a flash. Classic!!

            Come down to Mumbai y’all. Ain’t much you got to do there.

      2. Mishra

        You guys come to this country stealing jobs with fake resume, low wages. This is the fact that Mr. Trump and his admin knows about except Mr. Obama and Facebook CEO. Its time to end this loophole. Hire America 1st is the king.

        1. AZ

          Low wages? Are you getting 1000k by the way? If your knowledge if 50k worth, do you want the companies to pay you 1000k?

          What is your highest level of education? I bet that you can’t do my job. We are hard workers and we put our heart out in anything we do. We just done work for the pay.

          If we think you deserve 1000k, why are the companies not paying you 1000k? Pity you.

          You will be paid for what you have. Nobody is ready to give you 1000k even if we quit our jobs. Your lives will be in trouble if we don’t work.

          1. Mishra

            Without H1b and H4 EAD in the US market, our wage will be double the whatever existing wage (you said 50k, haha), we all know that except you moron from other countries. We will work harder than you if the wage is double. LOL

        2. Sn

          Performance through out the year and for years cannot be sustained in the basis of fake resumes/degrees. Companies require high skilled workers and these workers will not take low wages. Will instead go back to their respective countries. Neither will an American stay jobless over being little underpaid with low wage.

        3. Sn

          Sorry, also it is funny when you are aware that EAD holders are also equally high skilled and well qualified, in most cases. In fact those taking up odd jobs too are often holding a bachelors or masters. Please don’t be venomous. If companies favoured Indian educated individuals is only when they saw it more profitable. Not doing anyone favours.

    2. TK

      H4 EAD is the only thing that kept me hopeful of a solution to my dilemma in US. I have been away from my wife since 2 yrs now, waiting for my I140 to be approved so that my wife can work here and i can finally live a normal life in US, but based on this news i dont think there is any hope left for new H4 EADs. Life hits you in unique ways everday!! You just have to take it in stride and prepare for the next shock i guess!!

    3. Shikha

      How presumptuous you are to think like this. barring few cases most of the people who got work on This visa are with fake resume proxy interviews, accepted low pay rate thus bringing the whole market rate down for regular people. If a common man (regardless of nationality) goes out to buy apples will he pick the cheaper rate/lb or the same apple @expensive rate? The corporate greed is to blame …therefore now law prevailed ..
      About me- after being on h4 for 2 months went back to India (instead of blaming the system , country and staying here as well) and when I got h1 I came back to live the way I wanted. Now I am displaced by an unqualified h4ead candidate not because they are smarter than me but because they are will to work for half of my rate.

  26. AS

    Hopefully, better senses will prevail and plight of H4 EAD will be understood. But it so far is not clear as to what they intend to do with existing H4 EAD holders. Congress and Administration has to understand that they cannot justify on one hand saying Immigration is broken system and on the other try to revoke H4 EAD. Hopefully this news will garner enough attention to bring in support from like minded support groups. I am also not sure if this was done to show court that progress is made before Jan 2 hearing. It should be told clearly that H4 EAD is a product of EB2 and EB3 processing not justified for Indian and Chinese nationals.If they can fix EB2, EB3 issues, there will be no need to H4 EAD. But Administration need to first address EB2, EB3 issue before axing H4 EAD. Otherwise this will be unfair treatment for spouses.

  27. Sri

    H-4 Candidates have been fighting for this EAD for years and finally got it in 2015 but now within 2-3 years they want to remove. What a shame on governments and their policies and it looks like a completely a lobbying scenario and screw the H-4 candidates in their game plan. Very pathetic .. On the other hand they Green Card doesn’t move any far and Asians has to fight for that as well. It is completely broken system and legal non-immigration people are paying for that.

  28. SM

    This news is really disappointing h4 dependents. I have applied my EAD on September, but EAD cases are not moving from July. These agenda may be the reason behind the pending petitions. Back to back issues are attacking existing EAD. Let’s join together to save the EAD.

  29. Pc

    I just applied my ead last week and I was dreaming that I am not gonna fail in my career. Before getting it, they are publishing this falls agenda, I thought I have to wait for Jan 2,2018 to hear about court’s judgement. But one after other are coming to hit the EAD rule. Let’s wait to see the final judgement and other officialnews from uscis. Hope for the best..

    1. Lucky chap

      H4 EAD is started during obama era, current administration is rolling back everything obama did, without considering the facts behind his work. So, 90% this h4 EAD is going to be cancelled. What is the point in discussing about this and provoking the racists to write dirty comments here.

  30. SK

    This news is extremely disappointing. My wife completed her master’s here, had a better job than I have (and I’m doing pretty well for us) , did not get selected in the lottery and was forced to change to a H4 and when we finally saw a shimmer of hope after she got her EAD, this happens. I don’t think it just affects the dependents, it’ll affect the families and for me the future here looks bleak now. They will definitely regret passing this rule.
    The article here says that “We have no details on what happens to current H4 EAD holder working” but the screenshot above clearly says that labor turnover costs are anticipated which means H4 EAD will affect existing businesses who have employed H4s. I’m not completely sure but looks like anyone with the EAD will be affected

    1. priya m

      Nope, they will give sunset clause like DACA, 2 yrs or expiry. If they decide to cancel the xisting H4 EAD’s, it will attract law suits which the govt doesn’t want like Entrepreneur or muslim ban.

    2. priya m

      That clause indicates that based on Reddy & Neuman PC yesterdays discussion, how much economy loss the businesses will incur to find new replacements once current H4 EAD;s are removed.

  31. Srak

    This is a very sad news for my family. I am on H1B visa and have been working for a non-profit research institution for almost 10 years. I came for my masters and have been working in the same field and same institution since graduation. My husband is currently on H4 EAD and have been working in his field of study and experience through this EAD program. He is not a IT tech either. I do not see why we have to go through this revoking process when we have been here legally for many years and serving a non profit institution. This is very pathetic for families like us where the husband is on H4 EAD. What did we do wrong? I really hope we strongly raise our voice on the rule public comments. My family might opt to leave the country if this rule really ends the EAD. If we leave, as the rule highlights, this is a huge labor turnover cost for my company which is especially a non profit education institution.

    1. MD

      I am also really sad hearing this rule. I have a doubt here.
      If we do strong comments, will it have any effect ?
      What I meant is, If the administration is determined to repeal H4EAD , will they hear us?

      1. Mishra

        No help, don’t waste your energy and time.
        -Revoking H4 EAD is Trump’s ultimate goal starting his campaign. They already made their decision to end H4 EAD long time back.
        -Most of high tech companies actually don’t want to hire H4 EAD as they all know most of their experience are fake, and hiring them will eventually hurt company’s product quality.
        -The real techie H1b don’t want H4 EAD in the market as it will be more difficult for them to look for jobs (EAD can work for any employers with much lower wages)

    2. Mishra

      How could you have H1b for 10 years and not GC yet?
      Basically H4 EAD is stealing more American jobs than H1B, its also hurting wages. Majority of H4 EAD is dishonest.
      H4 EAD has to be revoked.

      1. Tat

        Feel pity on you… mishra do you know how many h4 ead’s are actually working.. only .01. Why you are fighting with h4 ead. I am also in h4 ead. Consider us a human being… i have very good experience and i got a full time job in a reputed organization with all the background check. So please dont push the statement like all h4 eads are fake. We are not fake. No employers are recruiting employees without background check… by name i think you are also an indian. Shame on you.. Keep in mind these politics will turn to you too once even if you are a citizen. You are not actual american keep in mind.

  32. K

    On the notification they said only certain H-4 spouses, which could mean certain H4 spouses will still get EADs. Let’s not draw conclusions till we see the details

    1. PM

      Mr K – rule it self is for certain H4 Spouses i.e those who have I-140
      With this now there is more uncertainty , negativity.

      There will be drop in % for college students opting for US
      There will be drop in % for International Talent
      There will be some economy impact in coming few years

      1. administrator
        Kumar

        Currently, it is very much an agenda item and what you see in the article above as screenshot is what it is. You can see the link above the screenshot. Look for December update in above article.

  33. desi banda

    I find it utterly appalling that some people here are rejoicing about the proposed rule to rescind the H4 EAD, what’s more surprising is that most of these people are disgruntled Indian tech-workers who are happy that their fellow Indians would be hurt by this decision. Shameless losers.

    1. Jeff vangalapudi

      I guess it should take 9-12 months for repeal to happen as there will be so many lawsuits. By major companies and all the tech giants will be together, AND OF COURSE THERES AILA. And if there’s a course case, it’s an easy win for EAD To survive, as no one on EAD is here illegally, and it’s white collar workers with professional degrees, and professionals that US can’t afford to lose. Also, we gotta make sure that there’s at least 50k comments from h4 EAD community(affected party), as DHS is bound to respond to every single comment in a detailed manner, and 50k+ comments will take months to respond to. ITS NOT A BAD NEWS YET. THEY FOUGHT THEIR BATTLE. NOW ITS OUR TURN. REMEMBER, INDIANS AND CHINESE ARE TOGETHER ON THIS. ITS A GOOD CHANCE TO SAVE IT. I AM POSITIVE.

      1. MD

        I am also really sad hearing this rule.

        I have a doubt here.(Please don’t consider this as a discouragement, just for doubt clearance)
        If we do strong comments, will it have any effect ?
        What I meant is, If the administration is determined to repeal H4EAD , will they hear us?

        1. priya m

          Frankly saying this is just a public stunt. They do what they decide and dont change it based on the comments. I will have to find some other place to continue my residency as my org doesnt sponsor visas and its exceptionally difficult

        2. Jeff vangalapudi

          It may or may not have and effect. But they will have to delay the rule by the time it takes to review and respond to every comment. And i have read its pretty strong, and rules and comments are there for a reason. No harm in trying. Let us see how it comes along.

      2. Tat

        I dont think so jeff.. they already decided to revoke this rule. I am also in h4 ead. Thus rule will affect me very badly. They will take all the comments but they will decide the final rule as they decided. Eg. i140 ead rule. Every one commended but atlast they not even consider comments. This public commenting system is just for name sake. I am not diacouraging anyone. try to find back plan.

    2. reddy

      All I can say its 50-50. I came here 11 yrs back and got GC until that time was working with consultant firm which you guys know take most of the share and due to recessions rates were very low. when the time passed competing for a job with opt dudes was hard as firms encouraged them for a low rate and they made money, who lost is H1b holders and then h4 came and again who gained consulting firms. So who got GC are little hope that they will get jobs faster and get fair share $. Everyone here wants to make fair amount and not less for what they deserve. I feel sad for whats going on but everyone has there own commitments. So we cant blame it as we cant change the system here.

      1. desi banda

        This is an intensely moronic problem with the Indian community everywhere- they want to go a foreign country and don’t want other fellow Indians coming there anymore. Let me hand you a fat paycheck simply because you came here 11 years ago, have a GC and that makes you deserve more, right? And just so you know- my cousin in 12th standard can write better code than most of you oldies out there.

        1. chandu

          Desi banda,
          As you mentioned intensely moronic problem with the Indian community everywhere. What people are opposed to is putting fake resume and ready to work for $20 or $30 and giving advantage to the consulting firms who has already looted a lot from employees. People who are already here for long time has to earn at least minimum to support their family. If that is not the case all of us are welcome any one that compete on fair grounds.

          1. Rahm Schilling

            Don’t make it sound like you are living in abject poverty that you find it difficult to even feed your family. You earn 2 times the median American family’s income in a year. What you will lose through this rule is that dream of yours to being a smug idiot who acts all high & mighty when you come down to India. What you will lose is that 4th parcel of land you will not be able to buy. What you will lose is that wish of yours to waltz around in a Merc.

            What an American family loses is the chance to work in their own goddamn country!

    3. Mishra

      Most of Indian tech-workers are happier to see H4 EAD revoked. It will eliminate the competition from H4 EAD when stealing American jobs.
      Actually its not as hurt as revoking DACA as their spouse are still working as H1b.

      1. Abhi

        Hi Mishra,

        You seem to hold a sizable grudge against H4EAD holders. Everyone has the right to hold a grudge– that’s fine by me. However, not everyone that works in the US and is from the Indian Subcontinent is an IT-tech worker. Question to you: What about non-IT workers who are able to work only because they have a H4EAD? What do you think should be said to them? Is it fair to snatch their right to work from them? It’s not the American way. By they way, you had asked a question to someone about being on H-1B and not having a green card. Let me tell you, sir, it is possible. The wait times for EB2 India is over 7 years.

      2. M

        Crazy you Mishra ! I trust my skills . If not US I will get it somewhere . I work on cloud and i will Be Given a job by anyone . H4 or citizens or anything doesn’t affect my skills ! That’s y they have h1 sir ! Maybe u only know the minority who come fake . Maybe u r omen amonst them ! Scared ?

      3. Lucky chap

        So, you are comparing DACA with h4, DACA are illegal immigrants, h4s are not. This is not about illegal immigration from the beginning. Want to keep all the people of color out.

        1. administrator
          Kumar

          It is not fake, it is published in Fall 2017 Regulatory Agenda. We have updated above article to reflect the new developments and official links as well.

  34. Jeff Vangalapudi

    Even if it’s decided to roll back the h4 ead, can’t the rollback be delayed by months and months if someone decides to file a case against the new regulation that rescinds h4 ead?
    Because oh law firm shared this view on their news bulletin on 18th November.that it will take months and months for repeal to happen. And infinity if a few court cases are filed.

    1. AZ

      I hope so. That’s so unfair and it should not happen. I have a Master’s degree here and I am on H4Ead. We are working for this country to make things happen. Who the heck on the earth thinks that H4Ead’s are not eligible? It’s not the Visa status, it’s your knowledge

      I have spent a lot for my career and I am working. Does everyone who is against this has a Master’s degree? How is the eligibility even decided? If you think you are eligible, compete with us and win the race.

      Why do someone from your country hire us ? Because they think we are better than you. Rather than changing the rules, change yourself and grow better.

      Damn rules!!

      1. TAM

        Ah, I see you don’t want to follow the rules of the land. It’s not the “skills”, it’s the right to work. Which you do not have.

        I have more than one master degrees and I disagree to H4B. Enough said.

  35. ASD

    There was a post on a Chinese Forum on H-4 EAD that the Trump Agenda will be released on Monday Dec 11. If anyone gets the link first please post here.

    1. VP

      Do not believe breitbart or any other news outlet just yet (breitbart is known for it anti immigrant stance) . DHS should announce something in the next few weeks

        1. VP

          @Kriti I said weeks not days. The reason for that is the court has only extended the deadline till 2nd of Jan, less than a month away. A request for an extension by DHS has been denied by the court. DHS has to respond before that with their decision. So we should see some statement from DHS in the upcoming 3 weeks or so.

    2. administrator
      Kumar

      Nothing is official. Do not be mislead. The latest speculation is from Breitbart News as updated above. Nothing is released by DHS

  36. Jk

    People are fighting on H4 and H1, while lobbyists are doing their job in White House. Can Apple start manufacturing in the US, please? That is not an H1B problem. Companies need to be profitable, so they choose their own way of making fat profits. Waste of time discussing this .

  37. Sophia

    China, India, and many counties get benefits from huge population. Look at the world and go back to history. By having more population, salaries, education and GDP are up. Everybody shared the benefits. Don’t you think the lottery of H1B is ridiculous enough? Not to mention the case trying to abandon certain H4 holders’ EAD. Please note, only certain H4, most Chinese and Indian, because their spouses can’t get I-485 concurrent with I-140. Each year, only 185K people get H1B, suppose 50% of them are married. Among who married, suppose 50% are Chinese and Indian. So H4 is up to 46K each year. Comparing to 40.5 M 24 to 65 ages people looking for a job in the U.S., it is really like a drop in the sea. Win the game by your ability not by changing the rule. Why L2 can work but not H4?

    1. SH

      Excellent point. If H4 spouses with EAD aren’t allowed to work, they should revoke work authorization of L2 spouses as well. “Save Jobs USA” isn’t fighting against that. Why???
      Most of the dependent spouses are in CA, NY, & NJ and there is no shortage of jobs there. If not for H4 EADs, these reqs will remain unfulfilled anyway. Atleast by employing spouses of H1B visa workers (with approved I140), both – the companies and employees are contributing to the economy.
      All of us who are facing such situation should unite and stand against this if Trump administration tries to revoke the rule

      1. GR

        Yes, people in my company who took away the jobs are on L1B visas and rest of the work is outsourced to India. I have known many people who work in IT jobs with L2 with minimum qualification. Why not L1 or L2? Removing H4 EAD would not give away these jobs to American instead would go to folks in India.

  38. B

    @ASD – H4 EAD revoke proposed rule already published in Fall Unified Agenda released today. Publicly will be released midnight. Goodbye and go home all H4 EADs. If you have signed up for notifications, you will get it or wait to hear the news with your coffee.

    1. Gautham

      Is this a rule developed by you? Don’t spread these kind of fake news. This is not a place to play fun on these things. This itslef proves what ever you said until this time were utter lies

      1. j1

        don’t chase down this guy. The frustrated guy just because someone took his job at TCS. I still had no idea why people complain about others and not improve their skill. Without skill, there is no way they will hire you at TCS. Wait not even small Indian IT company. haha

  39. Tech Talk

    If you are capable you would not loose a job. Rather than blaming on H-1B/H-4 EAD, train yourself to be competent. No one is giving free money. Capable ppl get jobs.

          1. BO

            I think then its TCS problem and not you or H4 EAD. Why TCS want to pay less money to someone as because that job really need that level of skill. TCS is smarter than you atleast i can tell.

            I have green card and my is on green card too so H4 EAD doesn’t bother me.

          2. VV

            You talk like a philistine. probably from a state school with a 2.7 GPA, if that. You know why we
            take your job ? Coz you are dumb as hell and only capable of working in coal mines or in construction.

          3. Na

            As a person from a Christian country( I am a Christian myself), I pity your selfish motive. I am an highly educated( 2 masters degree) waiting on finding a job with H4 EAD. I have to come back to the US with an H4 since I had to go back just after I graduated here in the US to marry the guy I fell in love with. This is a great country and everyone here are trying to find a job and live a better life. If you, an immigrant by law( a long time ago) think you qualify for a job and me, a present day immigrant doesn’t qualify….you are not being wise and just. Because, me and you compete for the same job with different knowledge set. Who wins the job justifies their smartness and knowledge. Trying to get a job by stopping the wise just makes you a loser anyway. Your heart know you are imcompetent…just to get a winner tag, all this ?? I pity you.

      1. F

        Oh Boy, when you weren’t even born, i was coding here. You are an example of bad parenting. You were not taught to respect others. Grow up.

    1. P

      So True !
      Jobs are given on experience and knowledge, this is what are the first rounds of interview, the pay questions are asked in the end when you pass these.

      If you are really capable pass these first rounds.

      Removing H4 Visa is just a shortcut you are trying to take by removing competition.

      Capable??? Keep the Visa and get in the market….oh wait…you already are and not getting jobs…hence you are upset…right !

      People here are trying to run the race alone and win it….if you really want to experience winning of the race…run with us and win it. Educate yourself.

      1. B

        Haha you are getting too personal . I can replace 20 of you offshore TCS coders . And ofcourse I charge twice of H1bs and probably 10 times of H4 eads . removing h4 ead is avoiding low skilled workers replace true American who belong here . Go to India and Work from there if you are that well skilled . Americans come first in USA . It’s not a race . It’s the country . You came here as a non immigrant worker and now asking for rights .How was the schooling in india with no toilets ?

        1. B*

          haha. So TCS don’t want to pay you twice as h1b because they know they don’t need high skill guys to do their support work. So TCS is more smart than you. If i own business and if skill need for work is $10/hr than there is no way i can pay 20$/hr for same work. So technically you were doing some low skill job before. You don’t deserve to have competition with H1B or wait not even H4 EAD. Haha! get some skill and don’t complain!

        2. M

          @B
          So you are charging in multiple of millions? If not then STFU. Because I’m on H1B and although I won’t disclose my numbers, you would have to be CEO of some big shot company to charge twice as much as me. So don’t give people the s**t that you are being paid more than H1B folks.

    2. Whitecollarslave

      This is nonsense. If you are not authorized to work, it does not matter how capable you are. Which world do you live in dude. Wake up and stop thinking you are superior than someone else encaustic you figured out your h1b

  40. Observer

    I am a beneficiary of H4 EAD and still believe that an administration has complete rights to make or scrap any law. Though solely stripping of laws made by the previous administration is not healthy of any organization.

    There are plenty of jobs and all of them prefer citizens.A qualified and talented person of any origin, can make a living anywhere in the world, under any circumstances. While weak hides behind reasons & blame the world. It’s a fair world, you can’t be ignored.

    First, they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you and finally you win.

      1. J1

        i think you said 30nov will be the day. I think that day is gone . where did you got that information before? at the barber shop? hahaha

        1. B

          Hello JK, H-4 EAD is gone my friend. Search in the Regulations Gov Site and it is mentioned that H4-EAD is go, going, gone. Link posting not allowed so search for “H-4 EAD Recipient Rule Review and Reconsider”

          1. J

            haha! I did and that is main reason i said you need to see doctor and not post your frustration here. Did you get another job or everywhere you got same cheap competition? hahahaha.

          2. JK

            B ~ Not sure if US gov makes rules and send personally to you in your dreams. I did not see any such rule. There is no authentic news on this. Gov is revisting H4 EAD and 1000 other thing ex: removing coutry cap, that everybody knows since new President came. There is case is court, that also everybody knows. But there is no final verdict on anything. Here you are taking about some final rule. Thats nowhere. I dare you to share an authentic link here suggesting there is a new rule which would be effective from a certain (exact) Data.

          3. JK

            B~ Where? this 15 day old link http://www.breitbart.com/big-government/2017/11/21/dhs-prepares-end-work-permits-foreign-h-1b-spouses/ ? That I had read before I became active in this thread. Yes DHS is preparing, whats new in that. I am asking about the outcome. Is there a new update?
            How hard it for you to post a link here?

Leave a Comment

Comments Policy :
  • Comments are to drive conversation, add your thoughts, experiences, ask questions!
  • Do NOT write hate speech, swear words, or get into fight. Maintain etiquette
  • Enter your Name, valid Email, URL(optional - Facebook, LinkedIn profile URLs).
  • Your email will NOT be published. Do NOT post any phone numbers, email-ids
  • Do NOT post any links from other websites, unless official sites, University websites.
  • By submitting your comment, you agree to Term and Conditions of our website.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.